This paper proposes a classification model of the financial reporting of Italian Local Governments (ILGs) and a grid of indicators supporting financial analysts in their solvency ratings. Due to their increased financial autonomy, ILGs increasingly need to resort to various forms of borrowing. However, the Basel II agreement requires financial institutions to carry out a thorough assessment of the creditworthiness of all potential borrowers, including ILGs. After reviewing the main criteria adopted by rating agencies for their analyses, this paper focuses on the assessment of the financial situation and debt position of ILGs. Such entities use a ‘financial’ accounting system based on commitment and ascertainment, to which the cash flow analysis model provided by IPSAS cannot be applied. The proposed classification model and the relevant grid of indicators were applied to the ILGs, differing in size but located in the same area, in order to test whether these tools could provide a thorough assessment of the financial situation of any LG. Finally, the study proposes an equation to define the maximum degree of indebtedness for an LG, in compliance with the limits set by the current regulations in Italy.